In an era dominated by instant streaming services, where viewers can access thousands of titles with a single click, the once-revolutionary concept of renting physical discs by mail has nearly faded into obscurity. Yet, amid this digital transformation, one company continues to offer this nostalgic service: GameFly. Best recognized for its video game rentals delivered through the postal system, GameFly quietly maintains a selection of DVDs and Blu-rays available for rent by mail, providing a lifeline for enthusiasts who prefer tangible media over cloud-based alternatives. This persistence stands out especially after the shutdown of similar offerings from larger competitors, marking GameFly as a unique survivor in a shrinking market.
You can sign up for 30 days free trial at Gamefly HERE and rent DVDs and Blu-rays by mail.
The shift away from mail-order rentals gained momentum when Netflix, the pioneer of the red-envelope delivery model, decided to discontinue its DVD-by-mail service. Launched in 1998, Netflix’s disc rental program revolutionized home entertainment by allowing subscribers to receive movies directly at their doorsteps without late fees or store visits. At its peak, it boasted millions of users and a vast library that included rare and independent films often absent from theaters or early streaming platforms. However, as streaming technology advanced and consumer habits evolved toward on-demand viewing, Netflix pivoted fully to digital content. The company announced the end of its physical rental operations in April 2023, with the final discs shipped out on September 29 of that year. This closure affected an estimated 1.1 to 1.3 million subscribers who had clung to the service for its extensive catalog, which at times exceeded what was available on Netflix’s streaming arm. The decision reflected broader industry trends, where physical media sales and rentals plummeted in favor of subscription-based streaming giants like Netflix itself, Disney+, and Amazon Prime Video.
With Netflix’s exit, attention turned to remaining options for those seeking physical discs without relying on kiosks or retail purchases. Enter GameFly, a service founded in 2002 primarily to cater to gamers by mailing console titles for platforms like PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, and others. While video games form the core of its business, GameFly expanded into movies years ago, offering DVDs, Blu-rays, and even 4K UHD discs as part of its subscription plans. This lesser-known feature allows users to build a queue of films, much like the old Netflix system, and receive them via U.S. Postal Service first-class mail. Delivery typically takes two to eight business days, with no due dates or late fees, giving renters the freedom to watch at their own pace. Subscribers can also opt to purchase rented discs at pre-owned prices if they decide to keep them.
GameFly’s movie library, though not as expansive as Netflix’s was in its heyday, includes hundreds of titles across genres, with around 292 DVD options alone, not counting Blu-rays. Pricing starts at approximately $8.95 per month for a basic plan allowing one movie at a time, scaling up to higher tiers for multiple discs or combinations with game rentals. For avid users, plans can go as high as $79.99 monthly for up to eight discs at once, with a limit of 16 per month. This flexibility appeals to niche audiences, such as collectors of physical media, fans of high-definition formats like 4K that may not stream well in all areas, or those in regions with unreliable internet. Unlike streaming, physical rentals ensure access to bonus features, director’s cuts, and uncompressed audio-visual quality that digital compression sometimes diminishes.
Despite its advantages, GameFly’s service isn’t without challenges. Availability can be spotty for popular titles, often marked as “low” or “very low” stock, leading to longer wait times. Delivery delays through the postal service remain a hurdle, especially compared to instant streaming. Customer feedback has highlighted issues with disc conditions upon arrival and occasional service hiccups, though the company continues to operate from its Los Angeles base. In 2026, as streaming subscriptions surge globally, GameFly’s mail-order model serves as a reminder of entertainment’s analog roots. It fills a gap left by Netflix’s departure, catering to a dedicated subset of consumers who value the tactile experience of handling discs and building personal collections.
As physical media production slows and more content goes exclusive to digital platforms, GameFly’s endurance could inspire a resurgence among retro enthusiasts or prompt further innovations in hybrid services. For now, it stands as the final bastion for those unwilling to let go of the mail-order era entirely, proving that in the fast-paced world of media consumption, there’s still room for the slow, deliberate joy of waiting for a package to arrive.
You can sign up for 30 days free trial at Gamefly HERE and rent DVDs and Blu-rays by mail.
Please add Cord Cutters News as a source for your Google News feed HERE. Please follow us on Facebook and X for more news, tips, and reviews. Need cord cutting tech support? Join our Cord Cutting Tech Support Facebook Group for help.