In a shocking move that sent ripples through the television industry, CBS announced the cancellation of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert after the 2025–26 season. Now Jimmy Kimmel Live is on hold also. The decision stunned observers, as the program remains the highest-rated late-night talk show, consistently outperforming The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon on NBC and Jimmy Kimmel Live! on ABC in total viewers and key demographic groups. To many insiders, The Late Show appeared untouchable, making the cancellation a perplexing development.
The timing of the announcement raised eyebrows. It came as Paramount, CBS’s parent company, was navigating the final stages of securing regulatory approval for its merger with Skydance, overseen by a Federal Communications Commission under the influence of President Donald Trump. Just a week after the cancellation was announced, the merger received approval. This proximity fueled speculation, especially given Trump’s public criticism of Colbert, including a call for his termination in the fall of 2024. However, CBS maintained that the decision was purely financial, citing losses of approximately $40 million annually for the show.
Industry analysis supports the plausibility of these figures. A network TV research analyst, with experience at networks other than CBS, estimated that losses for a show like The Late Show could range between $25 million and $40 million. The analyst’s financial model, built using Nielsen ratings, estimated ad pricing, and historical production costs for the major 11:35pm talk shows, revealed a grim reality: most network late-night shows likely ceased being profitable around 2022. The decline in linear TV ratings is the primary culprit. Since 2015, when Stephen Colbert succeeded David Letterman, Jimmy Fallon took over from Jay Leno, and Jimmy Kimmel moved to the 11:35pm slot, viewership in the 18–49 demographic for these shows has plummeted by 70–80% according to a report form LateNighter.
The erosion of ad revenue has been stark. In 2018, brands spent $439 million on network late-night television, according to advertising data firm Guideline. By 2024, that figure had halved. Digital platforms like YouTube have provided some relief, but their impact is minimal compared to the loss of traditional ad dollars. Late-night shows also face a unique challenge: their content has little to no syndication or streaming value. Unlike scripted dramas or sitcoms, topical humor tied to current events does not lend itself to international licensing or binge-watching.
Production costs, though lower than those of primetime scripted series, have become unsustainable in the face of shrinking revenues. In 2015, a typical 11:30pm talk show generated over $200 million in revenue with healthy profits. By 2023, these shows were operating at a loss, with deficits projected to deepen. Using standard forecasting methods, the analyst predicts that by 2030, losses for a typical late-night show could reach $70 million annually. Cost-cutting measures, such as reduced staff or scaled-back production, have been implemented across the major shows, but these efforts have not kept pace with rising expenses like talent salaries and other operational costs.
The broader decline in the economic viability of late-night television reflects a shifting media landscape. As audiences move away from linear TV, the once-lucrative 11:35pm slot has become a financial burden. For CBS, the decision to cancel The Late Show signals a reckoning with these realities, even as questions linger about external pressures influencing the move. The loss of Colbert’s platform marks the end of an era for late-night TV, with an uncertain future for the format as a whole.
Please follow us on Facebook and X for more news, tips, and reviews. Need cord cutting tech support? Join our Cord Cutting Tech Support Facebook Group for help.