The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) today announced the suspension of seven individuals convicted of defrauding its E-Rate program, a critical initiative designed to bring internet access to schools and libraries. The perpetrators, identified as Peretz Klein, Ben Klein, Moshe Schwartz, Simon Goldbrener, Sholem Steinberg, Aron Melber, and Susan Klein, were linked to a scheme that siphoned over $14 million in federal funds meant for educational technology. The FCC’s Enforcement Bureau has barred them from E-Rate activities and initiated proceedings to debar them for at least three years, underscoring a zero-tolerance stance on fraud as cord-cutting households—59.6 million in the U.S., per Evoca.tv—rely on robust digital infrastructure.
What Is the E-Rate Program?
Launched in 1996 under the Telecommunications Act, the E-Rate program (formally the Schools and Libraries Universal Service Support Mechanism) subsidizes internet access, telecommunications, and internal network infrastructure for eligible schools and libraries, particularly in underserved areas. Administered by the Universal Service Administrative Company (USAC) under FCC oversight, it provides 20-90% discounts on services, based on economic need, funded by the Universal Service Fund (USF) through telecom fees. In 2024, E-Rate disbursed $2.8 billion to connect 96% of U.S. schools to high-speed broadband, per FCC data, enabling digital learning and access to platforms like Google Classroom and streaming educational content.
Details of the Fraud and FCC Action
From 2010 to 2016, corporations controlled by the seven individuals requested over $35 million in E-Rate funds, primarily for private religious schools in Rockland County, New York. They received $14 million but failed to deliver much of the promised equipment, such as routers and wiring, instead submitting fraudulent invoices and false certifications, per a 2023 Department of Justice (DOJ) report. The DOJ sentenced the group between June 2022 and February 2023, with Peretz Klein receiving 48 months in prison and others facing 9-27 months, plus $2.6 million in restitution.
The FCC’s Enforcement Bureau acted swiftly, suspending the individuals effective upon notice or Federal Register publication, per agency rules. “Fraud has no place in FCC programs,” said Acting Chief Patrick Webre. “These programs serve vital public interests, not the enrichment of grifters.” The suspension bans them from any E-Rate involvement, including bidding or consulting, while debarment proceedings—allowing 30 days for response—could exclude them from all USF programs for three years or longer if extended. The FCC’s 2007 rules mandate such penalties for fraud-related convictions, like wire fraud, to protect taxpayer funds.
Broader Implications
This crackdown, supported by the DOJ, FBI, and Rockland County DA, highlights the FCC’s vigilance amid rising program demands—E-Rate applications hit $3.2 billion in 2024. It follows a 2023 case where the same individuals were prosecuted, exposing vulnerabilities in vendor oversight. X posts commend the FCC’s resolve, one user noting, “Taxpayers deserve accountability,” though some question if schools unknowingly benefited. The action aligns with broader efforts, like Google’s 2024 suspension of 39.2 million ad accounts, to curb digital fraud. As schools stream educational tools via Fire TV or Xfinity’s $55/month internet, ensuring E-Rate’s integrity remains crucial for equitable access.
Please follow us on Facebook and X for more news, tips, and reviews. Need cord cutting tech support? Join our Cord Cutting Tech Support Facebook Group for help. You can find Luke on X HERE.