In a striking shift for the television industry, pay-TV penetration in the United States has fallen to levels not seen since 1987, according to a new report from MoffettNathanson’s quarterly “Cord-Cutting Monitor,” as cited by Deadline. The report reveals that the penetration of linear video delivered by both traditional and streaming services like YouTube TV, has dropped to just 49.4% of occupied U.S. households. This marks a historic low, with traditional pay-TV operators—cable, satellite, and telecom—now serving only 34.4% of households.
The decline reflects a relentless wave of cord-cutting that has reshaped how Americans consume television. “Even if that’s the case, the numbers are still sobering,” said Craig Moffett, senior analyst at MoffettNathanson, in the report. The erosion of pay-TV’s dominance, which peaked at 88% household penetration in 2014, has been driven by rising costs, shifting viewer preferences, and the growing availability of premium content on streaming platforms. The report notes that traditional pay-TV lost nearly 12% of its subscribers annually, though there are signs the rate of decline may be stabilizing, with three consecutive quarters of slight improvement.
Virtual MVPDs like YouTube TV and Hulu + Live TV, initially seen as a lifeline for the pay-TV industry, have not fully offset the losses. While YouTube TV reported 8 million subscribers in Q1 2024, other virtual providers like Hulu Live and FuboTV have seen stagnant or declining numbers. MoffettNathanson estimates that virtual MVPDs now account for roughly 30% of pay-TV subscribers but predicts they could capture half the market by 2028. However, even these services face challenges as prices rise—YouTube TV and Hulu Live’s costs have surged 86% since their launch—and younger viewers increasingly reject scheduled programming in favor of on-demand streaming.
The report highlights a broader “impoverishment cycle” plaguing the industry. Rising sports broadcasting fees have driven up subscription costs, pushing entertainment-focused viewers toward cheaper streaming alternatives like Netflix and Disney+. Meanwhile, premium content, including sports, is migrating to over-the-top (OTT) platforms. For instance, NFL Thursday Night Football is now on Amazon Prime, and Disney’s upcoming standalone ESPN streaming service is expected to further accelerate the shift away from traditional pay-TV.
Despite the grim numbers, Moffett suggests a potential “bottom” for traditional pay-TV, where a core base of sports and news enthusiasts may remain. Disney CEO Bob Iger, speaking on CNBC, expressed optimism about combining linear and streaming services, calling it a “winning combination.” However, with pay-TV subscriptions projected to fall below 50 million by 2025, the industry faces an uncertain future as streaming continues to dominate.
This seismic shift underscores a cultural pivot toward flexibility and affordability in media consumption, leaving traditional pay-TV scrambling to adapt in an increasingly fragmented market.
Please follow us on Facebook and X for more news, tips, and reviews. Need cord cutting tech support? Join our Cord Cutting Tech Support Facebook Group for help. You can find Luke on X HERE.